James Scully’s ‘Smash or Pass’ game reveals his wildest stage door fantasies

James Scully. Photo: Luc Coiffait

“I’m going to start by saying this one is a smash,” says James Scully when presented with a photo of our favorite leading man from Oz. “I could pretend to pass Fiyero from Wicked, but that would be ‘pick-me’ behavior.”

Scully took a hard look at some of our favorite theater hotties in a game of “Smash or Pass” with Playbill. Scully is back in the hot seat with the original cast of Oh, Mary!, Cole Escola’s Tony-nominated (and Pulitzer finalist!) play about Mary Todd Lincoln’s secret desire to become a cabaret star. Scully plays Mary’s Teacher, but fans learned more about Scully than we ever could have imagined as he scrolled through notable characters from the stage as if

READ MORE OF THIS POST AT Queerty